Companies with women on boards fare worse on stock market
14 Aug 2009, 1307 Hrs

Add comment          Mail          Print          Write to Editor

Washington, August 14 Companies in which women are board members fare worse on the stock market, according to a study conducted by researchers at the University of Exeter.

The researchers have found that companies with female board members this face stockmarket prejudice despite performing as well on all other measures as those with all-male boards.

Writing about their observations in the British Journal of Management, they say that shareholders respond negatively to women being appointed to their boards, causing share values to decline.

The researchers conducted a comprehensive analysis of performance data from all FTSE 100 companies between 2001 and 2005, which found that companies with all-male boards had a market valuation equivalent to 166 per cent of their book value, while companies with at least one female board member had a market value equal to just 121 per cent of book value.

They, however, also noticed that appointing a woman to a company board did not compromise objective measures of financial performance, specifically, Return on Assets and Return on Equity.

In fact, they found that, as a whole, companies with women on their board were a far better investment than those without.

The researcher say that their findings suggest that shareholders systematically over-value companies with all-male boards, while being unenthusiastic about the appointment of women to senior positions.

They say that this is despite there being no evidence that women's appointment has an adverse impact on company's performance.

The findings also fit with previous research from the University of Exeter which has shown that women are appointed to leadership positions when a company is in crisis. Dubbed the 'glass cliff' phenomenon, this trend involves women being placed in precarious positions when there is a high risk of failure. This has led to women being associated with weak performance.

Lead author Professor Alex Haslam, a psychologist at the University of Exeter, said: "Our study shows very clearly that shareholders tend to devalue companies with women board members and to chronically over-value those with all-male boards. What is not clear is whether this is because shareholders feel that women perform less well on boards than men or whether they see a woman's appointment as a signal that the company is in crisis. Whatever the reason, it is clear that this response is unwarranted, because there is no objective evidence that having female board members damages a company's performance. If anything, the opposite is true." (ANI)

Related Latest

Two women hurt as bulls flee Tom Cruise, Cameron Diaz' film set Robert Pattinson says women always dump him Working women nag hubbies to feel more feminine: Study Nearly 50 percent of Indian women marry before 18: Unicef More women should be associated with self-help groups: Rahul Gandhi Buoyant stock market, economy doubles billionaires in India HIV infected women sell nutritious food items in Gujarat First women navigators commissioned in Indian Navy Sensex volatile, ruling 0.61 percent in red First Indian Navy women aviators take charge

Related Latest

What kind of China at PM's banquet? Security beefed-up in Mumbai ahead of 26/11 anniversary Test match against India starts from scratch, says Sangkkara Sonia Gandhi assures support to wives of Hemant Karkare, Vijay Salaskar Indian sub-continent is prone to nuclear war: Army Chief Chhattisgarh man, a snake venom junkie Centre to set up six Spice Parks Widows of 26/11 martyrs meet Sonia 'Pigeon' McGrath still as miserly and deadly as in his hey-day India -ASEAN free trade agreement to come into force in January 2010

• What kind of China at PM's banquet?
• Security beefed-up in Mumbai ahead of 26/11 anniversary
• Test match against India starts from scratch, says Sangkkara
• Indian sub-continent is prone to nuclear war: Army Chief
• Sonia Gandhi assures support to wives of Hemant Karkare, Vijay Salaskar

• भारतीय क्रिकेट की मजबूत दीवार
• कंगारूओं के आगे ढेर, चीतों से कैसे मुकाबला करेंगें शेर
• Reducing greenhouse gases may not be enough to slow global warming
• बीकानेर महापौर चुनावः एक विश्लेषण
• Deepawali: The Festival Of Lights